Chapter 347: Confusions
“How is she?”
Roland set down his pen and looked up at Nightingale, who had appeared in the office without a sound.
“She’s fallen asleep. Had a bowl of oatmeal first — good appetite.” Nightingale crossed to the table and settled into her usual chair. “Silvio’s watching her now.”
“That’s something.”
“Do you believe what she told us?”
“Once we remove the God’s Stone of Retaliation tomorrow, you’ll be able to judge for yourself whether she’s lying.” Roland paused. “But I think most of it is true.”
“Why?”
“Have you noticed anything strange?” He laced his fingers under his chin. “She’s a woman from four hundred years ago, yet she speaks exactly the same language we do. Two territories separated by the Impassable Mountain Range — that kind of linguistic unity is virtually impossible unless both territories share a common origin and maintained regular contact.”
“She called the Four Kingdoms the Barbarian Land.”
“That’s precisely the point.” He leaned forward. “I don’t know what this region looked like four centuries ago. Maybe it was nothing more than scattered villages — criminals and outcasts exiled from the witch world. The kingdom’s history books place the founding of most major cities at two or three hundred years back, and it was roughly that same period when the astrologers appeared.” He paused, something clicking into place behind his eyes. “It always puzzled me that astrologers — who never produced any notable research — were called ‘sages,’ the same honorific as alchemists. Now I think I understand. The Union fled here with their survivors, their language, their civilization entire. They mixed with the locals, and helped them build the regimes and fortresses and cities that eventually became the Four Kingdoms.”
“You say it as though you watched it happen.” Nightingale shook her head, smiling.
“It’s the only explanation that fits.” Roland spread his hands. “We speak her language because we came from the same source. And over those four hundred years, civilization has been rebuilding itself — painstakingly, without ever quite recovering what was lost.”
“Well.” Nightingale rested her chin on one hand. “You’ll have your answer tomorrow. And if your theory is wrong, you owe me a luxury lunch.”
The luxury lunch was a specific thing: corn soup, roast chicken drumstick, ice cream bread. It was served once a week, and Nightingale had strong opinions about it.
“And if you’re wrong?”
“Whatever you want.” She tilted her head, a slow squint, the line of her cheek and throat catching the candlelight in a way that made the thought difficult to complete. There was an old saying that any gesture made by a beautiful person looked like an invitation. Roland was beginning to believe it.
“I’ll keep that in mind,” he said, with two deliberate coughs, and turned back to his notebook.
Agatha had only recently woken after four decades of frozen sleep. Roland hadn’t wanted to press her too hard in their first session — he’d followed her train of thought rather than guiding it, which meant the information he’d gathered was disordered and full of gaps. What he was doing now was reconstructing it: sorting the fragments, identifying what he still needed to know.
The most pressing matter was the demons.
What had started the war? Why had they stopped? Neither question had a clean answer. Demon behavior defied the usual logic of territorial conflict — they hadn’t occupied the Barbarian Land. They hadn’t plundered it. What they’d done looked, from a distance, like slaughter for its own sake.
Agatha had also used the phrase Battle of Divine Will. Two sides locked in war under the will of God — but at that time the Church hadn’t existed yet, and the singular God the Church proclaimed had no precedent. Without accounting for that, nothing settled correctly in Roland’s mind.
He would also need to understand the basic shape of the Holy City’s civilization: how it was fed, how it governed itself, how it measured economic capacity. He needed that information to understand what kind of force the Union had actually been, and to extrapolate the demons’ capabilities from it.
The Union itself didn’t worry him as much as the Magic Stones did. Tilly’s account suggested those stones could compensate dramatically for a witch’s unstable abilities — they could extend a witch’s effective range, turn auxiliary witches into combatants. But Roland’s instinct ran the opposite direction: he’d rather turn all the combat witches into factory workers and build industrial capacity instead. Sending witches into war with Magic Stones was putting the cart before the horse.
What he couldn’t explain was why the Union — a civilization overflowing with witches — had chosen to build the God’s Punishment Army rather than leverage those stones. Magic Stones had obvious limitations, or their production was prohibitively difficult. He didn’t know which yet.
Fortunately, Agatha had been a member of the Quest Society — something like an alchemy workshop, but focused on Magic Stones and the nature of magical power itself. A society of highly talented witches, dedicated to research. There was information there he hadn’t yet begun to extract.
The last column in his notes was circled: The Church.
He couldn’t expect Agatha to explain the Church’s origins or internal development — she’d been frozen since before any of that began. But from the scattered things she had said, he could already build a rough picture. The Church had been founded after the witches’ defeat. It had taken what the Union knew and buried it, declaring witches the embodiment of evil — a useful lie, given that the conquered population would have no civilization of its own, no written history, nothing to push back against a fabricated theology. The four kingdoms’ population, descended from those original outcasts, would have been especially vulnerable. No records, no competing tradition.
But something didn’t fit.
The Union had possessed Bliss Warriors, Extraordinary Witches, even Transcendents. Even armed with God’s Stones of Retaliation, how had the Church managed to destroy an organization that powerful? Pure hatred was not sufficient. Some military force, some structural advantage, some piece of the puzzle was still missing.
He drew a question mark next to the circle.
“That witch seems to dislike you,” Nightingale said.
“She comes from a world where witches were the ruling class.” Roland set down his pen. “To her, I’m probably indistinguishable from roadside weeds.”
“Does that bother you?”
“Why would it?” He shook his head. “She’s a woman abandoned by her own era. She went into that coffin with an entire civilization behind her and woke up to find four hundred years had passed and everything was ash. Of course she’s afraid. Of course she builds walls. Once she’s had time to take in what’s actually around her, she’ll probably see things differently.”
Nightingale smiled at that — quietly, to herself — and said nothing for a moment. Then: “Don’t worry. I won’t let her treat you badly.”
Chapter 347: Confusions
Translator: Meh/TransN Editor: – –
…
“How is she?” Roland asked. Roland put down the pen, looking up at Nightingale who had just quietly appeared in his office.
“She’s fallen asleep. Before that, she had a bowl of oatmeal. It seems that she had a good appetite.” Nightingale went to the table and sat back in her old place. “Now it’s Silvio’s turn to guard her.”
“Well, that’s not bad.”
“Do you believe what she said?” Nightingale asked.
“With the God’s Stone of Retaliation being removed, you can easily judge if she is lying when you question her tomorrow, but…” Roland paused for a moment, “I think most of what she said is true.”
“Why do you think so?” she asked curiously.
“Have you noticed that as a person from 400 years ago, she’s using the same diction and language as us?” the prince said with his hands propping up his chin. “Theoretically, such a situation would be almost impossible for two territories separated by the Impassable Mountain Range, unless these two territories were of the same origin and had frequent contact.”
“But she called the Four Kingdoms the Barbarian Land.”
“That’s the point … I don’t know what the scene was like 400 years ago. Perhaps all this used to be was just a few scattered villages and some criminals exiled by the world of witches. The Kingdom’s history book also
records that the age of the major cities was generally between 200 and 300 years, and astrologers also came into existence during that era,” he said with great interest. “It had always bewildered me that the astrologers, who generally had no achievements nor research findings, were also called ‘sages’, the same as alchemists. Now I think I’ve got my answer—the Union fled to this borderland, and brought with them the survivors, their language and civilization. These people mingled with the locals, and helped the latter build the regime, fortress and city.”
“You speak as if you’d seen it happening.” Nightingale shook her head, smiling.
“This is the only way we can explain why we’re using the same language as her,” Roland said earnestly, “because we’re of the same origin. And during these 400 years, civilization was constantly in the process of rebuilding without the slightest opportunity of advancing past where it used to be. “Alright,” she said with her hands laid out, “anyway, you’ll know the answer by tomorrow, and if your guess is wrong… then you’ll have to give me a ‘luxury lunch’.”
The so-called luxury lunch was composed of corn soup, roast chicken drumstick and ice cream bread and was usually only served once a week.
“What if you’re wrong?”
“Whatever you want,” said Nightingale, tilting her head and squinting. The perfect curve formed by her cheek and smooth neck was exceptionally beautiful. “Regardless of what kind of movement an attractive person makes, it will always look seductive.” Roland finally believed this saying.
“I will bear that in mind,” he said with two coughs, turning his attention back to his notebook.
Since Elsa had only recently awakened after four decades of sleep, Roland didn’t want to press her to give accurate and detailed answers to all his questions. For the most part, his questions followed her train of thought, and the information he gained was quite disordered as a result. What he was
doing at the moment was to rearrange the information he gleaned from Elsa, and to find out the key points he had to know next.
Undoubtedly, the most pressing problem was about the demons.
What was the cause of the war with the demons, and why did the demons cease fighting? This information was essential to Border Town. No war could have been started without a reason, but the demons’ behavior didn’t seem like an attack motivated by resources or expansion. They didn’t occupy the Barbarian Land, nor did they pillage mankind. What they did seemed like an act purely for the joy of slaughter.
Roland also noticed that Elsa mentioned the term Battle of Divine Will. Could it be that the two sides waged the dreadful war under the will of God? But at that time, the Church hadn’t come into being, so there wasn’t the one and only God that the Church declared. Without this explained, his mind remained unsettled.
Meanwhile, he needed to figure out the basic necessities of life in the Holy City’s civilization as soon as possible, or in other words, assess its degree of economic and civil development. He needed this information to measure the level of this civilization and deduce the demons’ capabilities.
As for the Union, Roland wasn’t too concerned about it. Its witches were scarce and their abilities were unstable. This organization’s capability for organized combat wouldn’t be very high. Historical experience had repeatedly stressed that before the formation of a generation gap, a comprehensive war was all about attrition. A few sophisticated weapons wouldn’t reverse the overall disadvantage.
The second question was about the Magic Stone.
Considering what Tilly said, the magical nature of such stones could greatly compensate for the witches’ unstable ability, enabling the witches to exert powers that didn’t belong to them. In this way, even auxiliary witches could be sent to war. However, in Roland’s point of view, that was like putting the cart before the horse. He’d rather turn all the combat witches into auxiliary witches and put them all to work in production roles.
Oddly enough, the Union, which had large numbers of witches, didn’t make use of Magic Stones to fight against the demons. Instead, it chose to produce God’s Punishment Army, which in Roland’s view was beyond comprehension. Maybe the Magic Stone had some unknown shortcomings, or its production was extremely difficult?
Fortunately, Elsa was a member of the Quest Society, an organization similar to the current Alchemy Workshop, which gathered a group of highly talented witches specializing in the research of Magic Stones and magic power. Roland faintly felt that there must be a wealth of potential information to be exploited.
The last question was about the Church.
He drew a circle on this column. Obviously, he couldn’t count on getting details from Elsa about the organization’s foundation and development. What he could infer from the scattered information at hand was that the Church was founded after the witches’ defeat. After obtaining the Union’s secret, the Church concealed everything about the witches and declared them as incarnations of demons. If the people of the Four Kingdoms were seen as descendants of aborigines, the Church would be a veritable outsider. Since the aborigines didn’t have their own civilization, they could be easily fooled by fabricated history and prophecies.
“Was it only because the witches used to suppress ordinary people that the refugees took the witches as their enemy and went on to hunt the witches on this continent?” Roland frowned. “All these deductions did sound reasonable, yet… he felt that there was something wrong.”
The Union had a great number of Bliss Warriors, Extraordinary Witches, and even Transcendents. Even if the Church managed to get a hold of God’s Stones of Retaliation, was it possible for them to defeat an opponent like the Union?
To wipe out a much stronger force, you couldn’t purely rely on hatred. Clearly there was some key information missing.
“That witch seems to dislike you,” Nightingale suddenly said.
“After all, she used to live in a world where the witches were considered superior to the human being.” Roland laughed. “I’m afraid I’m just no different from the roadside weeds in her eyes.”
“Don’t you hate her?”
“Why would I? She is nothing but a poor woman abandoned by her own time.” He shook his head. “She’d been sleeping in the frozen coffin for 400 years, and woke up to find the world had completely changed. The strangeness brought by the new world would bring her fear, so it was no surprise that she would build a defensive wall in her heart. After she accepts all this, she will probably gradually change her point of view.”
“What a typical response of yours,” said Nightingale with a smile. “But rest assured, I won’t allow her to offend you in any way.”